New York City

Truth: Why Did Cuomo Really Fire RIOC President Rosenthal?

Home » Truth: Why Did Cuomo Really Fire RIOC President Rosenthal?

RIOC President Susan Rosenthal was fired unexpectedly by Governor Andrew Cuomo on Friday, June 19th. Sexually and racially offensive language, his office claimed, was the cause, but it now appears she may be a victim of political correctness run amok. Or an in-house coup in which her accuser fronted for others seeking gains from her dismissal.

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

By David Stone

Roosevelt Island Daily News

Rosenthal Models Face Mask
Susan Rosenthal: Leading by example during the COVID crisis.

UPDATE June 23rd, 2020: Details on Rosenthal’s firing emerged yesterday. The Roosevelt Islander obtained a copy of an email thought to trigger the event. The sender copied dozens of officials, but RIOC keeps it an in-house secret.

The Roosevelt Island Daily/News knows who sent the letter, but we are keeping that information silent, for now. That’s partly because we doubt she acted alone and are developing a broader picture.

No one challenged her accusations on merit or whether they justified her harsh dismissal, a fact suspicious in and of itself.

Lingering doubts…

Arousing more suspicion is the fact that, although RIOC’s board fired Rosenthal and replaced her with VP Shelton Haynes, there is no record of any meeting as required by state law. There was never any public notice nor do we know if there was a quorum. No minutes are online nor is there a record of the meeting on RIOC’s website.

What’s with all the secrecy and backroom dealing? Who made the decisions, and why?

RIOC’s policy of silence when faced with difficulty remains, and the ousted president cannot defend herself. But she deserves a defense, and piling on a defenseless victim shines a bad light on Roosevelt Island.

If the email is really the spark for her dismissal, Rosenthal’s major faults may be no worse than a sense of humor and a taste for African-American art.

Let’s start with the art…

The accuser is first aggrieved over, believe it or not, artwork:

Last year Ms. Rosenthal purchased a painting named “The Cotton Picker” which depicted a slave picking cotton. The painting was placed it in her office until she decided to take it to her home. She faced no repercussions. In addition to making staffers feel uncomfortable, we also felt disrespected.

Anonymous Accuser

But in reality, The Cotten Picker is a new work by an African-American artist, and Rosenthal bought it at a Black History Month exhibit at Gallery RIVAA.

RIOC president Susan Rosenthal at the 1619 Project event.
Susan Rosenthal appeared at Gallery RIVAA’s Black History Month Exhibit, speaking forcefully in support of efforts to unearth truths from our nation’s past.

Rarely is support for living African American artists this twisted in making a case.

Who could take this seriously?

Accusations of Racism

Rosenthal’s daughter married an African American man, and her well-known off-the-cuff humor comes through. But her accuser finds offense in her remark that her “son in law is black as hell and her daughter is white as snow.”

This her accuser learned from eavesdropping on a resident visit to Rosenthal’s office.

And she finds more grounds for complaint.

“When her first grandchild was born, she also mentioned that her grandchild was ‘the real African American.'” 

That, the accuser asserts, is “extremely appalling,” but does not explain why.

Rosenthal’s as well-known for adoring her grandkids as she is for her humor, and instead of appalling, those who know her are likely to see this as pride.

But perhaps most disturbing, an objection to a phrase most commonly used to counter stereotyping African Americans: “…not all black people look alike,”

How was that spun into something offensive?

A sense of humor further at risk…

Saving the worst for last…

The sexually offensive comment chucked into the mix for Rosenthal’s firing…

“She has also mentioned in meetings with internal and external parties, that the last time she trusted someone she lost her virginity.”

Sorry, this made me laugh.

And if that’s actionable, everyone whoever cracked a joke’s in trouble.

That would include me because I’ve made far worse, at least by the standards set by Governor Cuomo and RIOC.

End of Update

RIOC President Rosenthal Fired

Although short on details, Rosenthal’s dismissal brings to a close her four year tenure as president at the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation. In the first year, she was “acting” after serving as lead counsel under Charlene Indelicato.

The surprise comes as RIOC works its way out of restrictions caused by the coronavirus crisis.

And it comes before the dust settled on a controversial firing of two high level managers, earlier this month.

We covered Cuomo’s appointment of her in 2016: Cuomo Thumbs His Nose At Roosevelt Island, Installs Unqualified RIOC Leader.

First NYC Ferry landing on Roosevelt Island
In 2017, Susan Rosenthal was the first person to arrive for work at the new Roosevelt Island Ferry Landing.

Aggressive improvements in infrastructure marked her work, but that will be tempered by a reputation for favoring developers over residents. In recent years, RIOC’s grown more opaque, slow walking FOIL requests and dodging news inquiries.

Rosenthal is 72 years old. She is an experienced lawyer.

RIOC President Rosenthal’s Fired by Cuomo Out of the Blue

According to an article in the New York Post, where her dismissal was first reported, an unidentified employee accused Rosenthal of “inappropriate language” and other “inappropriate conduct.” 

No more details were available. There was a statement by Cuomo senior adviser Richard Azzopardi.

“This investigation substantiated that the president had used racially and sexually offensive language, in clear violation of state policy and the strict standards set by this Administration. The President was immediately terminated,”

Richard Azzopardi, Cuomo Senior Advisor

We will bring you a review of Rosenthal’s tenure on Roosevelt Island in the coming days, but this writer, among others, will miss her gregarious nature while acknowledging serious disappointments.

But no RIOC leader has ever been perfect, and few, if any, had as significant an impact as Rosenthal.

Vice President of Operations Shelton Haynes is now Acting President/CEO at RIOC.

Latest from Roosevelt Island News

Tugboats in the East River, Winter, New York City, Fine Art Photography Print

©Deborah Julian. All rights reserved.

One for the books…

Original WFF Animal Sanctuary in Southpoint

A look back. It’s June, 2018, and RIOC Sparks the Cat Sanctuary Water Crisis and All That Follows

The cat sanctuary water crisis, caused for still unexplained reasons, flared in late spring, 2018. By the end of June, it ended, but repercussions vibrate into 2021 with dried up water fountains and unanswered health concerns. As we put away the original Roosevelt Island Daily, this month, we’re preserving a few articles of special worth.…

Keep reading
The 2020 cat sanctuary crisis involved this well-built, generous structure.

Before the 2020 Cat Sanctuary Crisis, RIOC’s Boohooing and Evasion

The 2020 Cat Sanctuary crisis resolved in December, the state agency returning to its senses. But two years ago, their first assault was just as mean, albeit a lot more whiney and ridiculous. Here’s our report from 2018, updated.

Keep reading
anonymous man with book in hand

RIOC board member, clear conflicts of interest, big votes, but why no disclosure…?

RIOC conflicts of interest for board member Michael Shinozaki loom large but remain publicly undisclosed. He does not abstain from voting, and he’s open with opinions. But why no disclosure…?

Keep reading
Cherry Trees in the public space.

RIOC’s out of sight switch seeks benefit for pal Hudson-Related

In a last minute move, RIOC seeks a benefit for Hudson-Related, disregarding public wishes, at its December board meeting. The state agency wants the real estate giant off the hook for building promised restrooms at Firefighter’s Field. But there’s plenty of disturbing action going with it.

Keep reading
New Roosevelt Island Tram

Already in full bunker mode, RIOC now digs in deeper

RIOC digs in deeper, embracing magical budgeting and pushing back against community outreach. At an unannounced Audit Committee meeting, RIOC’s bunker mode was in full force.

Keep reading

Roosevelt Island COVID mobile testing site draws long lines. What you need to know for Day Two

Lines formed early before Roosevelt Island’s COVID-19 mobile testing site opened. Weather was damp and a little chilly, but spirits were high along the hour-long line. By David Stone Roosevelt Island News Roosevelt Islanders waited months for testing. “The first person to be tested arrived at the big bell (in Good Shepherd Plaza) at 5:30…

Keep reading


Something went wrong. Please refresh the page and/or try again.

9 replies »

    • Last seen, President of Bluestone Developers after VP at Battery Park City Authority, but he’s a Republican. It’ll be curious to see who comes in next. Unless this is less sudden than we know and someone’s waiting in the wings, it will take a while.

      Fasten your seatbelt.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.