A Different Way

Will the State Marijuana Bill Pay Off for Black and Brown New Yorkers?

Clifford Michel, THE CITY

Logo for THE CITY
This article was originally published
on
by THE CITY

Home » Will the State Marijuana Bill Pay Off for Black and Brown New Yorkers?
The Columbia Care medical marijuana dispensary in Downtown Brooklyn, May 29, 2020.
The Columbia Care medical marijuana dispensary in Downtown Brooklyn, May 29, 2020. | Hiram Alejandro Durán/THE CITY

The landmark deal struck by Gov. Andrew Cuomo and the state legislature Thursday to legalize recreational marijuana in New York State reportedly includes one of the country’s most ambitious social equity programs.

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

But advocates say they’re prepared to keep a careful eye on whether New York can avoid pitfalls that have swallowed some other states’ efforts to bring a fair share of the multibillion-dollar legal pot business to Black and Hispanic citizens.

The New York bill is expected to include language that’ll set aside about half of sales licenses for people of color, women and people related to those with a past marijuana conviction. The measure would also provide capital to minority- and women-owned firms. 

“New York is really on the precipices right now of ushering in a new era of marijuana justice,” said Melissa Moore, the Drug Policy Alliance’s New York State director.  

Hundreds of people packed into Union Square for a rally advocating the legalization of recreational marijuana use, May 4, 2019.

In recent years, some of the 14 states that have legalized recreational marijuana have attempted to address social inequities caused by over-policing past cannabis use in communities of color. 

Some states, though, have shown less than stellar results

In Illinois, for example, the state legislature was vocal about people of color being able to gain a foothold in the legal cannabis industry. But nearly 15 months after the law went into effect, no marijuana dispensaries in the state are owned by people of color. 

“In Illinois, in Massachusetts and other places where there are social equity programs, it becomes really difficult for people’’ with a record of marijuana-related convictions, Moore said. “It’s virtually impossible to get the normal sort of small business loans.”

Cannabis advocates in New York are hopeful that a combination of grants, low-interest loans and a business incubator program supplying technical assistance could make the difference. 

Home-Grown Relief

Cuomo made several concessions from his own initial legal pot proposal, including disallowing home-grown cannabis and allocating $100 million in tax revenue to go toward grants for communities hit hard by marijuana policing in recent years. 

Now some 40% of tax revenue will be earmarked for social equity and New Yorkers will be able to grow up to six plants in their homes, The Wall Street Journal reported. 

Assemblymember Crystal Peoples-Stokes (D-Buffalo), who wrote the Assembly’s version of the recreational marijuana bill, recently told THE CITY that Cuomo’s community reinvestment proposal wasn’t enough on its own. 

“One thing that is important to bring clarity to is that social equity is a lot different than community reinvestment. It’s two separate things,” said Peoples-Stokes. “Social equity is included in the opportunities and licensing structures, and financial support services to make sure that minority-owned Black businesses have an opportunity to be in the cannabis business.” 

New Yorkers of color — the vast majority Black and Latino — were hit with 94% of pot-related arrests and summonses in 2020, according to an analysis of NYPD data by The Legal Aid Society. 

Professor Kathryn Miller, who leads the Cardozo Law School’s criminal defense clinic, said the bill goes far in addressing racial inequities, but added there are still some loopholes police can exploit.

“What does continue to happen is that police officers use their observations of people using marijuana or claim to smell the smell of marijuana as an excuse to have an interaction with that person,” Miller told THE CITY.  

“Police will still have a basis to go up to young Black and brown men, and now I can ask this person about warrants or now I can stop this person or frisk this person,” she added. “So, unless there’s full decriminalization, which it seems unclear to me at best from coverage that that’s the case here, I don’t think we’ll see radical change that I’d like to see from this legislation.”

THE CITY is an independent, nonprofit news outlet dedicated to hard-hitting reporting that serves the people of New York.

Latest from Assorted Ideas, Large & Small

New York Skyline, Early Autumn Sunset in FDR Four Freedoms State Park

In FDR Four Freedoms State Park, the most serene space in all five boroughs, an early autumn sunset outlines the New York skyline. So near while still so far away… Also from Assorted Ideas, Large & Small

Keep reading

“Nothing Crushes Us…” True. One Year Ago in Greenwich Village

“Nothing Crushes Us,” a poster on University Place in Greenwich Village, a sign of New York City unity. Outdoor dining was just beginning to get a foothold, and a year later, it proved right. We aren’t out of it yet, but we’ve stuck together, no matter what divisions the mass media sells, day after day.…

Keep reading

Not just Billy Joel, everyone’s in a New York State of Mind. Listen.

NYCNext corrals the best New York City voices, from rap to Broadway, across the spectrum, in a New York State of Mind… singing celebration of love. I’ve literally got nothing to add. I can’t sing, anyway, but these men and women sure can. And it’s a love song. Listen. More from Assorted Ideas, Large &…

Keep reading

Loading…

Something went wrong. Please refresh the page and/or try again.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.